NHLFanCentral

Zuma

Team Canada’s bold Macklin Celebrini move over Sidney Crosby sparks major criticism

Team Canada’s decision to keep Macklin Celebrini as captain even after Sidney Crosby joined the team has become one of the biggest talking points of the 2026 IIHF World Championship.

The decision earned Team Canada authorities some significant backlash from former NHL player and analyst Jay Rosehill. He labeled the decision a blasphemy and said no player should wear the “C” over Sidney Crosby on a Canadian national team. According to him, Crosby’s reputation alone should have made the decision automatic.

Rosehill vocalized his thoughts with an X update that read, "Giving a 19-year-old kid the Captaincy of a team that Sidney Crosby is on is basically blasphemy. He’s got years and years to be a leader, why not give him the opportunity to watch the best in action? It would only benefit him down the road."

Apparently, Rosehill feels Macklin Celebrini has enough time to become a leader in the future. He also suggested that Macklin Celebrini would have learned more if he had played under Sidney Crosby instead of captaining the team at such a young age.

Canada named 19-year-old Macklin Celebrini as captain before Sidney Crosby joined the team. Rosehill's rightful captain joined the team after the Pittsburgh Penguins’ playoff exit.

There were expectations that Crosby would take the captain role because of his leadership and international success as Captain Canada. However, Team Canada reportedly decided to keep Celebrini in the role after discussions within the locker room. Crosby agreed to serve as an alternate captain, which surprised many in the hockey world.

Since the 2010 Vancouver Olympics, this is the first time Crosby has not served as captain for Canada in a major tournament.

Has Macklin Celebrini Already Proven Team Canada Right?

It may still be too early to say anything about Celebrini's captaincy because the sample size is small. However, Canada's early results have portrayed the decision to make him the captain as an effective one.

In the first two games, Macklin Celebrini has played well. He recorded 3 points, and Team Canada won both games comfortably. 

Under Celebrini, Canada beat Sweden 5-3 in the first game and then crushed Italy 6-0 in their next fixture. Crosby has mostly played a supporting role so far. He has quietly helped with defense and mentorship instead of taking the spotlight.

The debate, however, is unlikely to disappear anytime soon. Some people believe Crosby should have received the captaincy because of his experience.

Others believe Team Canada made the right decision because it gives Macklin Celebrini valuable exposure and helps prepare him for leadership in future tournaments.

No matter what people think, this is still a huge achievement for Celebrini. He became the youngest captain in Team Canada history. And if he leads Canada to a gold medal, it will make the moment even more special.

So, do you think the Team Canada management was right to pick Clebrini as the captain over Crosby?

Read more at the NHL Fan Central

Written by

Kapil Manghnani

Edited by

Souvik Roy